I've reviewed shade #3 'Cream Coral' previously but actually bought both at the same time (yay 1+1 sale events). The Creammellow range by Innisfree is perfect for the colder months, with a very moisturizing formula (containing Camellia Oil) that hides my terribly flaky lips.
I've yet to find another Korean lip product that combines strong pigmentation, a neutral red shade and wearable, moisturizing texture (plus affordable pricing...) and believe me, I've been searching.
The Creammellow line was a follow-up to the Color Glow Lipstick by the same brand, sporting a creamier, heavier texture but similar design. Overall, the colors are also more durable, glossy and the release was autumn-themed, with the marketing focusing on deep or muted/nude shades.
Back then, finding good MLBB nude-ish shades or darker reds was still a bit of a struggle in the very brightly colored Korean lipstick world, so I went with the mentioned Cream Coral #3 and Moist Dewy Red #8 for their novelty.
The rose gold accents differentiate the Creammellow lipsticks from the Color Glow's silver ones.
Fair warning: I do find the actual color just a tad cooler than the official swatches suggest. Just the tiniest bit, but still, for red hues, that can make all the difference depending on what you're looking for.
It depends a bit on the lighting, and strangely on the amount of layers I apply. The first layer seems slightly cool-toned, but a second layer goes away from pink undertones and leaves me with true red lips.
|One lightly dabbed-on layer.|
|Second layer on top for stronger pigmentation.|
|Really like the even adherence to my lips and how the Creammellow lipstick makes|
them look healthy and moisturized.
HUGE PLUS: This lipstick leaves an actual stain! The swatch on my arm left a red stain even after 8 hours and being washed off with water. It's a bit less forgiving around oily foods, but still, the staining power does pack a punch.
|(Direct sunlight) - stain left after eating noodle soup and doing outdoorsy stuff for a couple hours.|
The color lasts about 3 hours without eating, and fades very prettily without settling into lip lines or leaving uneven color - something Innisfree has managed really well with their lip products in general.
|One layer, cloudy day natural lighting.|
I'm getting old lol...
Now for the sad part:
It seems the Creammellow line has been discontinued. They don't show up on the Korean innisfree site anymore (the Color Glow line has disappeared a few months earlier, too), having been replaced by the Real Fit Creamy Lipstick line.
Ironically, my review of the #3 Cream Coral lipstick literally ended with: "They won't run away." Nope, they ran.
While the Creammellow lipsticks are still available in global online shops, I did find a possible replacement for this particular shade. #4 of the Real Fit Creamy lipsticks is called exactly the same as #8 here, and the color does look similar (I never trust official swatches, though) if more warm. The finish seems more glossy, but again, that might just be the swatch and lots of Photoshop.
|The new Real Fit Creamy line, #4 Moist Dewy Red|
On that note, other shades of the Creammellow range that pop up in the new Real Fit Creamy range:
Creammellow #4 Warm Coral Grapefruit Tea is Real Fit Creamy #2.
Creammellow #7 Cherry Red is Real Fit Creamy #3.
Sadly, my old fav #3 Cream Coral is nowhere to be seen.
I want to take a look at those in store to compare the texture, too.
|Some red lipsticks age me by about five years, so now that I've turned 28, I love that this one DOESN'T.|
Future restocking options aside, I really love this shade and line in general.
- Strong, buildable pigmentation
- Brightens complexion instead of aging up
- Creamy texture that blends out lip lines and hides chapped lips
- No need for lip balm before use
- Very moisturizing
- Leaves a red stain
- Fades evenly
- Wearable red hue for daily use with one layer
- Strong enough for evening makeup with two layers
Affordable at 12000\ per lipstick, the new Real Fit Creamy line retails at the same price.
Thank you for reading! :D Have a grumpy Hedwig to finish...
|Two layers of the lipstick #8 - I like how well this shade works for casual settings, too!|